Find Sully the Stabber
Get Sully's Autograph
Get Sully's Head
Turn in: Tiny Tina
Never meet your heroes.
Collect autograph for Tiny Tina
A Green Pistol, e.g. "Disinfecting Quickshot":
A Green SMG,e.g. Bandity Smig:
Tiny Tina: "Just bring me his autograph and you'll be my favorite person ever! Forever!
Tina may not have gotten the autograph but she got something much more meaningful instead: another death on her conscience!
Just kidding. Tina doesn't have a conscience
Number One Fan Walkthrough
After talking to Tiny Tina in the Badass Crater of Badassitude and grabbing the piece of paper from her, go to The Beatdown. Follow the mission marker to find Sully the Stabber, who isn't very cooperative, so kill him, and get his pick up his head. Then go back to Tiny Tina to turn the mission in.